
I had some brutal insomnia last night. The upside is that when I’m excessively tired, I shift into a little bit more of right brain thinking. I had been contemplating if there was some common connection between all of the misinformation and lies that have come about during the COVID pandemic. It dawned on me that I could plug the Myths section of my website into a few LLMs and see what they could find. I put that in the back of my head until this morning.
I used the same prompt for all three:
I have a bunch of myths listed on this page. https://icemsg.org/myths/
I would like you to go into each of the individual pages that are linked and review them. For each, I want you to deeply seek online for the first individuals, groups, or organizations that started putting out each particular myth I’ve addressed. I would like the links to the earliest know place where they occurred online broken down as a list corresponding to each myth. Take as long as needed to do a very extensive search to determine where each myth originated.
I found the output of each interesting.
ChatGPT
Yes. I went through the current Myths index and began tracing each claim backward rather than simply looking for fact-checks. One important finding is that the page has 21 current myth pages, including several that were not present in an older crawl of the index. (Infection Control Insights)
There is also an important methodological issue: for most of these claims, there is no provable single “originator.” A meme may have circulated privately before the first surviving public post, and many claims existed in slightly different wording before the recognizable version appeared. So I would distinguish:
- Earliest surviving online occurrence I can locate
- Earliest identifiable prominent promoter
- Person/group that appears to have substantially popularized the claim
- Confidence in the attribution
- Whether the claim actually originated with that person, versus merely being amplified by them.
Based on the research so far, here is the preliminary origin map.
Preliminary origin/propagation map
1. “Flatten the Curve” Didn’t Work
Earliest identifiable counter-narrative: This one is unusually complicated because criticism began almost immediately after “flatten the curve” became public-health terminology.
The phrase itself was being used by March 2020, with explanations of its purpose appearing by March 11–12, 2020. (GovTech)
By May 2020, people were already arguing online that the curve had supposedly been flattened and that the rationale for restrictions had therefore disappeared. A May 9–10, 2020 Reddit discussion is an early surviving example of that narrative. (Reddit)
A much stronger early formulation came from critics of lockdowns who argued that mitigation had failed to flatten the curve. An especially useful primary-source trail is the congressional testimony/document in which this argument was explicitly made:
Early congressional document arguing that mitigation failed to flatten the curve
The document says that the evidence supposedly showed mitigation efforts had “failed to flatten the curve” and contrasts New York/New Jersey with Sweden. (GovInfo)
Assessment: I would not attribute this myth to one individual yet. The earliest form appears to have emerged from the broader lockdown-opposition movement during spring/summer 2020.
Likely important propagators: lockdown critics, including the Great Barrington/anti-lockdown intellectual ecosystem and later prominent social-media commentators.
Confidence: High that the claim was circulating by May 2020; low that a single originator can be established.
2. “99% Survival Rate”
This one has a very good early trail.
A Facebook post from April 14, 2020 claimed a 98.54% COVID survival rate. PolitiFact documented it on May 7. (PolitiFact)
By May 20, 2020, a Facebook meme was circulating claims of 99.983% survival, and Lead Stories documented the specific poster, Michael Reeves, on May 20. (Lead Stories)
But the broader “99% survival” formulation appears to have been circulating considerably more widely. By July 2020, Donald Trump was publicly saying that 99% of U.S. COVID cases were “totally harmless.” (Wikipedia)
It was subsequently heavily promoted by figures including Ron Paul, who used “99%+ survival rate” in November 2020, and Candace Owens, who used the same statistic in December 2020. (PolitiFact)
Earliest surviving example found: April 14, 2020 Facebook post claiming 98.54%.
Earliest specific identifiable poster found: Michael Reeves, May 20, 2020, for the 99.983% version. (Lead Stories)
Major political popularizers: Donald Trump, Ron Paul, Candace Owens, among many others.
Assessment: The evidence does not support saying Trump invented it. It was already circulating on Facebook by April. Trump substantially amplified the broader minimization narrative later.
Confidence: High.
3. “Clot Shots”
This is one of the easiest to trace.
The earliest surviving uses located by Barry Popik are:
- March 13, 2021 — Twitter user “dingus”: “Aka The Blood Clot Shot”
- March 13 — Lishka: “blood clot shot”
- March 15 — matty: “blood clot shot”
- March 19 — Tyler: “Clot-shots”
- March 31 — Millennial Rose: “Clot shot” referring to AstraZeneca. (Barry Popik)
Urban Dictionary subsequently recorded “Clot Shot” on April 17, 2021, specifically as a nickname for the Johnson & Johnson COVID vaccine. (Barry Popik)
The terminology arose in the immediate aftermath of genuine reports of the extremely rare clotting syndrome associated with AstraZeneca/J&J vaccines. The FDA/CDC pause of J&J occurred April 13, 2021. (JNJ.com)
Earliest located occurrence: Twitter, March 13, 2021, user “dingus.”
Popularization: anti-vaccine Twitter/social-media communities.
Later prominent promoter: Dr. Ryan Cole publicly called COVID vaccines “clot shots” in 2021. (Latin Times)
Important distinction: the nickname originated during discussion of a real but rare adverse event. The later claim that COVID vaccines broadly cause dangerous clotting is a different proposition.
Confidence: Very high for the earliest online use of the term.
4. “COVID Is Renamed Influenza”
This one has a remarkably strong origin candidate.
On December 20, 2020, a Parler dataset recorded the claim:
“Influenza has been renamed COVID”
The statement was attributed to a “maverick epidemiologist.” (PubMed Central (PMC))
Five days later, the idea was developed into an article published by Just the News, December 31, 2020, titled:
“The missing flu riddle: ‘Influenza has been renamed COVID,’ maverick epidemiologist says”
The person quoted was Knut Wittkowski, former head of biostatistics, epidemiology and research design at Rockefeller University. He explicitly said:
“Influenza has been renamed COVID in large part.”
This is a very strong candidate for the first major identifiable promoter of the exact modern claim.
Earliest located social-media occurrence: December 20, 2020.
Prominent originator/promoter: Knut Wittkowski.
Major amplification: Just the News and subsequent COVID-skeptic communities.
Confidence: High, although I would still phrase it as “earliest identifiable formulation I have found” rather than absolute proof of invention.
5. “Do Your Own Research”
This one did not originate with COVID.
The Harvard Kennedy School Misinformation Review specifically traces “do your own research” as a slogan to American conspiracy theorist Milton William “Bill” Cooper in the 1990s. It subsequently became heavily used by anti-vaccine communities. (Misinformation Review)
So the correct genealogy is approximately:
Bill Cooper / 1990s conspiracy culture → alternative-health/anti-vaccine communities → COVID conspiracy ecosystem.
This is an important distinction because saying that a particular COVID influencer “invented” DYOR would be incorrect.
Origin: Bill Cooper-era conspiracy culture, 1990s.
COVID-era popularization: anti-vaccine influencers and social-media communities.
Confidence: High.
6. “From COVID vs. With COVID”
This has an unusually clear documented inflection point.
On April 7, 2020, White House Coronavirus Task Force coordinator Deborah Birx said:
“if someone dies with COVID-19, we are counting that as a COVID-19 death.”
That statement was immediately seized upon by critics.
The following day, Rush Limbaugh explicitly turned Birx’s statement into the “with vs. from” argument, saying that if someone died “with” COVID rather than because of it, the government was nevertheless counting the death as COVID. (Rush Limbaugh Show)
This is arguably the most important early propagation event.
There were criticisms of COVID death classification before April 7—including discussion of deaths with underlying conditions—but Birx’s statement became the centerpiece of the modern “with COVID vs from COVID” narrative.
Earliest major identifiable promoter: Rush Limbaugh, April 8, 2020.
Triggering statement: Deborah Birx, April 7, 2020.
Other early promoters: Daily Caller, Fox News commentators, Scott Jensen and other critics of COVID mortality accounting.
Rush Limbaugh’s April 8, 2020 discussion of “with” versus “because of” COVID
Confidence: Very high for the early propagation pathway.
7. “I Had Mild COVID, I’m Fine”
This is different from the others because it is not really a single conspiracy theory with a traceable inventor.
People were legitimately reporting mild COVID from early 2020 onward. The mythical inference—“I had a mild case, therefore COVID can’t cause significant long-term damage”—developed as a form of anecdotal reasoning.
By late 2020 and 2021, long-COVID communities were specifically documenting people who had initially experienced mild illness and subsequently developed persistent symptoms. (Reddit)
For example, a December 2020 account described a very mild initial infection followed months later by fatigue, sleep problems and shortness of breath. (Reddit)
Assessment: No defensible single originator.
Earliest likely form: ordinary personal anecdotes beginning in 2020.
Later misinformation mechanism: “I was fine after COVID, therefore COVID is harmless.”
Confidence: High that this cannot responsibly be attributed to a single individual.
8. “It’s Just a Flu”
This is another one with a very strong early political record.
Donald Trump said on February 26, 2020:
“This is a flu. This is like a flu.”
The same day he described the risk as low; on February 27 he said the virus would disappear. (Wikipedia)
Trump subsequently compared COVID to ordinary flu repeatedly.
However, he did not invent the comparison. The broader “COVID is just flu” narrative was already circulating internationally in early 2020. A scholarly review of pandemic folklore documents claims from the beginning of the outbreak that the disease was “just a flu” or a hoax. (SIEF Home)
Earliest major U.S. political promoter located: Donald Trump, February 2020.
Important caveat: not necessarily originator.
Confidence: High regarding Trump’s early promotion; low regarding a single originator.
9. “It’s Not a Risk for the Healthy”
This one has two important early propagators.
On April 9, 2020, Vanity Fair profiled former New York Times reporter Alex Berenson, who was becoming a prominent COVID skeptic. Berenson told Sean Hannity:
“kids, children, almost anybody under 30 is at no risk to this—no serious risk from this virus.”
Another major intellectual source was Jay Bhattacharya, whose March 2020 Wall Street Journal commentary questioned universal lockdowns and later whose Great Barrington Declaration advocated allowing lower-risk people to live normally. (TIME)
The distinction is important: Bhattacharya’s position was about risk stratification and policy, not literally “healthy people cannot be harmed.”
Early prominent promoter: Alex Berenson, March/April 2020.
Major later intellectual amplifier: Jay Bhattacharya / Great Barrington Declaration.
Confidence: Moderate-high.
10. “It’s Not Dangerous for Children”
Again, there is a traceable early ecosystem rather than one inventor.
In March 2020, legitimate medical discussion emphasized that children were at lower risk of severe disease, which was true relative to older adults. For example, Harvard experts were saying children could be infected and generally fare well while simultaneously warning that they could amplify transmission. (Harvard Chan School of Public Health)
The misinformation emerged when “lower risk” became “no risk.”
By April 2020, Alex Berenson’s messaging included the claim that children/people under 30 faced essentially no serious risk. (Vanity Fair)
Later, Texas Senator John Cornyn publicly questioned whether children could even catch or transmit COVID, prompting experts to emphasize that lower risk did not mean zero risk. (NBC Dallas-Fort Worth)
Early prominent promoter: Alex Berenson.
Political amplifiers: Donald Trump and other politicians who emphasized children’s low risk.
Confidence: Moderate-high.
11. “Ivermectin for COVID”
This one is especially interesting because the underlying scientific story is not fabricated. Ivermectin really did attract scientific interest.
The Monash University laboratory study by Leon Caly and colleagues was published/preprinted on April 3, 2020, reporting an in-vitro antiviral effect. (BIRD Group)
That laboratory result rapidly became the foundation for the much stronger claim that ivermectin was an effective COVID treatment.
By May 2020, countries including Peru and Bolivia were incorporating/distributing ivermectin despite inadequate clinical evidence. (Sage Journals)
The subsequent online promotion involved a large network rather than one person: Andrew Hill, Pierre Kory, the FLCCC, various South American clinicians, and later figures such as Simone Gold, Peter McCullough, Robert Malone, etc.
Earliest scientific trigger: Caly et al., April 3, 2020.
Earliest large-scale treatment/policy propagation: South American medical/political networks, April–May 2020.
Important: It would be historically inaccurate to say “anti-vaxxers invented ivermectin for COVID.” The hypothesis originated from a genuine laboratory experiment; the misinformation came from extrapolating in-vitro findings into unsupported clinical claims.
Confidence: High for the scientific starting point; more difficult for the misinformation origin.
12. “Masks Don’t Work”
This has a fascinating genealogy because there was an actual early public-health messaging failure/transition.
On March 3, 2020, U.S. Surgeon General Jerome Adams tweeted that masks were not effective for preventing the general public from catching coronavirus. The tweet was subsequently widely cited by people arguing masks “don’t work.” (Hacker News)
On March 17, Reddit users were already discussing the contradictory mask guidance. (Reddit)
By April 2020, the statement had become part of the anti-mask narrative. An April 10 post by Indian politician/lawyer Prashant Bhushan explicitly promoted “Masks Don’t Work,” based on a paper by a U.S. cardiologist. (TheQuint)
Later, Scott Atlas became one of the most prominent U.S. political promoters. His October 18, 2020 tweet saying masks didn’t work was removed by Twitter. (CNN Transcripts)
Earliest major official statement that became the meme’s seed: Jerome Adams, March 3, 2020.
Earliest identifiable anti-mask social-media propagation: March–April 2020.
Major later promoter: Scott Atlas.
Confidence: Very high.
13. “Natural Immunity Is Better Than Vaccination”
There are actually two different origin stories.
The scientific observation that infection can generate strong immunity predates COVID vaccines and was never inherently misinformation.
The COVID-specific political claim that natural infection is superior to vaccination can be traced quite clearly to Senator Rand Paul.
FactCheck.org documented a November 19, 2020 tweet by Paul claiming that naturally acquired immunity was better than vaccine immunity. (FactCheck.org)
The claim subsequently became much stronger during the Delta period, especially following studies showing that previous infection could provide substantial protection against reinfection.
One 2021 systematic review actually concluded that natural immunity could be at least equivalent to vaccination in some populations, illustrating why the historical record needs to distinguish the legitimate scientific question from the later “therefore don’t vaccinate” conclusion. (PubMed Central (PMC))
Early identifiable political promoter: Rand Paul, November 2020.
Later major promoters: various anti-vaccine physicians and media outlets.
Confidence: High for the early political version.
14. “Omicron Is Mild”
This one is particularly tricky because Omicron really was generally less severe on a per-infection basis than Delta. The misleading version was the leap from that fact to “Omicron is mild/harmless.”
Omicron was first identified in November 2021. By early December, public discussion was already describing it as potentially less severe. On December 10, 2021, for example, the CDC director was being reported as saying that early cases appeared mostly mild. (The Guardian)
By December 14, the UK Parliament was discussing whether Omicron was “milder.” (Hansard)
Scientific literature subsequently explicitly examined the narrative “Omicron is mild,” while noting the difference between reduced intrinsic severity and the enormous number of infections. (PubMed Central (PMC))
Assessment: Unlike “COVID was renamed influenza,” this did not originate as a pure conspiracy claim. It evolved from a genuine observation that was stripped of context.
Confidence: High that there was no single originator.
15. “Side Effects on Vaccine Package Inserts”
This is another one where the underlying information is genuine but the inference is often misleading.
The important distinction is between:
“The package insert lists adverse events observed during trials/postmarketing surveillance”
and
“Everything listed on the package insert was proven to be caused by the vaccine.”
The latter interpretation appears to have emerged very early in vaccine misinformation.
I would classify this one as not having a defensible single originator unless we narrow it to a particular viral meme or particular package insert.
16. “The Flu Magically Disappeared”
This is closely related to the “COVID is renamed flu” conspiracy but is historically somewhat earlier.
The underlying observation was completely real: influenza activity fell dramatically during the 2020–21 season.
The conspiracy interpretation—“flu disappeared because COVID numbers are actually flu cases”—was circulating by late 2020.
The strongest identifiable early promoter overlaps with the previous myth: Knut Wittkowski, whose December 2020 statement that influenza had been “renamed COVID” was published by Just the News. (Just The News)
The Parler study independently recorded the “influenza has been renamed COVID” claim on December 20, 2020. (PubMed Central (PMC))
Likely early originator/promoter: Knut Wittkowski.
Confidence: High for the December 2020 documented version, but not absolute proof he originated the idea.
17. “The Vaccines Were Rushed”
This one appears almost immediately when vaccine development accelerated in late 2020.
By December 11, 2020, Washington Post reporting was already discussing fears that vaccines had been rushed without adequate testing. (The Washington Post)
By December 18, CNN was explicitly treating:
“The Covid-19 vaccines were too rushed. We cannot know if they are safe.”
as a major vaccine myth. (KVIA)
The concern was not confined to the political right; survey research subsequently found that people across communities were concerned about long-term safety and the speed of development. (PubMed Central (PMC))
Origin: diffuse vaccine-hesitancy ecosystem in late 2020.
Notable catalyst: Operation Warp Speed and the extraordinarily rapid development timeline.
Confidence: High that this is a distributed-origin claim rather than one person’s invention.
18. “Vaccine Turbo Cancer”
This one has a relatively clear chronology.
The phrase “turbo cancer” began trending online in late 2022, according to multiple retrospective investigations. (Contagion Live)
Reuters was already fact-checking claims linking COVID vaccines to “turbo cancer” in December 2022. (Wikipedia)
The claim was subsequently popularized heavily by Dr. William Makis, and later promoted by figures including Harvey Risch. Science-Based Medicine identifies Makis’s promotion and dates Risch’s subsequent amplification to 2023. (Science-Based Medicine)
The term itself therefore appears to have emerged in late 2022, while Makis became one of its principal medical-sounding advocates in 2023.
Earliest period: fall 2022.
Major early popularizer: William Makis.
Later prominent promoter: Harvey Risch.
Confidence: High on the chronology; moderate on the exact first individual who coined it.
19. “Vaccines Don’t Stop Transmission”
This one requires very careful wording because the statement has changed meaning over time.
COVID vaccines were never 100% effective at preventing infection or transmission. Even the FDA’s November 2020 review explicitly stated that data were limited regarding vaccine effects on transmission. (Regulations.gov)
But the later absolutist claim—
“vaccines don’t stop transmission, therefore vaccination provides no meaningful transmission benefit”
—is different.
By July 2021, CDC investigations documented breakthrough infections and acknowledged that vaccinated people could transmit SARS-CoV-2. (Children’s Health Defense)
The anti-vaccine movement then used that fact to claim vaccines simply did not stop transmission.
Important finding: this is not a myth in the literal sense if “stop” means “completely prevent.” The misleading part is treating imperfect prevention as zero effect.
Earliest documented scientific caveat: November 2020 FDA review.
Major misinformation phase: July 2021 onward.
Confidence: High regarding chronology; low for a single originator.
20. “VAERS Proves Massive Injury and Death from COVID Vaccines”
This one has a very strong early anti-vaccine ecosystem.
The critical error is treating a passive adverse-event reporting system as a database of causally confirmed vaccine injuries/deaths.
The National Vaccine Information Center/MedAlerts was already analyzing VAERS data aggressively during the first months of vaccination. A July 2021 submission, for example, calculated enormous alleged underreporting factors from VAERS. (Regulations.gov)
By 2021, claims that thousands of people had died from COVID vaccines were widespread. A later University of Missouri analysis describes headlines such as:
“COVID-19 Vaccine-Related Fatalities Exceed 6,000.”
A 2022 mathematical analysis explicitly identified the underlying argument as the claim that VAERS demonstrated that hundreds of thousands of Americans had been killed by COVID vaccination. (arXiv)
Major early promoter: National Vaccine Information Center / Barbara Loe Fisher-associated vaccine-opposition network.
Later major promoters: Jessica Rose, Steve Kirsch, and others.
Confidence: High that the claim emerged from established anti-vaccine VAERS activism rather than from a single COVID-era inventor.
21. “We Don’t Know the Long-Term Effects of the Vaccine”
This one is another technically nuanced case.
In late 2020, it was literally true that nobody could know the 10-year or 20-year effects of a vaccine that had only recently been developed.
The misinformation leap was:
“We cannot know 10-year effects yet” → “therefore the vaccines are likely to have dangerous long-term effects.”
By February 2021, major pediatric/medical organizations were already specifically addressing the concern about unknown long-term effects. (Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia)
Survey research subsequently documented that people were explicitly citing unknown long-term effects as a reason for vaccine hesitancy. (PubMed Central (PMC))
Origin: distributed vaccine-hesitancy movement, late 2020.
Not attributable to a single person.
Confidence: High.
The most interesting origin findings
Several of these are much more traceable than I initially expected.
| Myth | Earliest useful origin point I found | Principal early promoter | Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flatten the Curve Didn’t Work | May 2020 | Lockdown-opposition movement | Moderate |
| 99% Survival | Apr. 14, 2020 Facebook | Multiple; later Trump/Ron Paul/Owens | High |
| Clot Shots | Mar. 13, 2021 Twitter | “dingus” + early Twitter users | Very high |
| COVID = renamed flu | Dec. 20, 2020 Parler | Knut Wittkowski | High |
| Do Your Own Research | 1990s | Bill Cooper | Very high |
| From vs With COVID | Apr. 7–8, 2020 | Deborah Birx → Rush Limbaugh | Very high |
| Mild COVID = fine | 2020 anecdotes | Diffuse | Low |
| Just a flu | Feb. 2020 | Donald Trump was an early major U.S. promoter | High |
| Healthy aren’t at risk | Mar./Apr. 2020 | Alex Berenson among early major promoters | Moderate-high |
| Children aren’t at risk | Mar./Apr. 2020 | Berenson/other political commentators | Moderate |
| Ivermectin | Apr. 3, 2020 lab study | Caly et al.; later many promoters | High |
| Masks don’t work | Mar. 3, 2020 official messaging → anti-mask movement | Jerome Adams was an important accidental seed; Scott Atlas later | Very high |
| Natural immunity better | Nov. 19, 2020 | Rand Paul | High |
| Omicron is mild | Nov./Dec. 2021 | Diffuse; based partly on genuine evidence | High |
| Package inserts prove side effects | 2020–21 | Diffuse | Low |
| Flu magically disappeared | Dec. 2020 | Knut Wittkowski / COVID-skeptic network | High |
| Vaccines were rushed | Nov./Dec. 2020 | Diffuse vaccine-hesitancy network | High |
| Turbo cancer | Fall 2022 | William Makis prominent early popularizer | High |
| Vaccines don’t stop transmission | 2021 | Diffuse; later anti-vaccine movement | High |
| VAERS proves deaths | Early 2021 | NVIC/anti-vaccine VAERS network | High |
| Unknown long-term effects | Late 2020 | Diffuse vaccine-hesitancy movement | High |
One particularly important correction to the “origin” concept
I would not describe every person above as the person who “started the myth.”
For example:
- Jerome Adams did not invent “masks don’t work.” He made an early official statement that subsequently became ammunition for the anti-mask movement. (Hacker News)
- Deborah Birx did not invent the “COVID deaths are inflated” conspiracy. Her April 7 statement became the raw material for Rush Limbaugh and others. (Rush Limbaugh Show)
- Knut Wittkowski may not have invented “flu was renamed COVID.” But I have found unusually strong evidence that he was one of the earliest identifiable prominent people to formulate and popularize that exact claim. (Just The News)
- Caly et al. did not invent ivermectin misinformation. Their April 3 laboratory experiment was legitimate research; the misinformation arose when the in-vitro result was treated as proof of clinical efficacy. (BIRD Group)
- “Omicron is mild” isn’t simply misinformation. Omicron was genuinely less severe per infection in many studies; the misleading part is ignoring its enormous transmissibility, reinfections, population immunity, age distribution and cumulative hospitalization/death burden. (PubMed Central (PMC))
- “Vaccines don’t stop transmission” is also semantically tricky. Vaccines never provided perfect sterilizing immunity. The misinformation is generally the transformation of “doesn’t completely prevent transmission” into “has no effect on transmission.” The FDA’s November 2020 documents actually acknowledged that transmission data were initially limited. (Regulations.gov)
What I would do for the final version
For your website, I think the strongest product would not simply be a list saying “Person X invented Myth Y.” That would make several entries historically vulnerable.
I’d instead build each myth as a miniature provenance investigation:
Myth: COVID is renamed influenza
Earliest occurrence located: December 20, 2020
Earliest identifiable prominent promoter: Knut Wittkowski
First major publication located: Just the News, December 31, 2020
Evidence: [links]
Confidence: High
Caveat: Earlier deleted/private social-media posts may exist; I cannot establish Wittkowski as the literal inventor.
And then provide a chronological chain of 3–10 links showing:
first occurrence → early amplification → major influencer → mainstream spread → current version.
That approach would be considerably more defensible than claiming an absolute origin when the historical evidence can’t support one.
One other thing I noticed during this research: your current index contains 21 myths, whereas the earlier version of the page that the search index initially returned had only 17. The current page includes “Do Your Own Research,” “From COVID vs with COVID,” “Side Effects on Vaccine Package Inserts,” and “The Flu Magically Disappeared,” among the additions. (Infection Control Insights)
If this is intended to become a reference-quality resource on ICEMSG, I would recommend going one step further and documenting the earliest surviving URL for every myth, the date, author/account, archived copy where possible, and a confidence grade, because that will make the page much harder to attack on the grounds that you are merely labeling controversial claims as misinformation.
Copilot
See my thinking
You’re asking a really forensic question here—“who lit the match” for each myth—not just who amplified it. For most of these, the honest answer is: we can identify early documented propagators and key amplification points, but not the very first person or post. The internet doesn’t preserve every tweet, Facebook post, forum thread, or deleted blog, so “earliest known” will always be approximate.
Below is a best‑effort mapping, with links to early, traceable online origins or major early amplifiers for the myths where the record is reasonably clear. For the rest, I’ll flag why a precise origin can’t be pinned down.
Myths with reasonably traceable early online origins
| Myth (your page) | Earliest traceable online propagator / amplifier | Link | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Myth: The Flu Magically Disappeared | Fox News graphic + Donald Trump Jr | AFP Fact Check on misleading flu statistics and “fake pandemic” claims | AFP traces a widely shared Fox News graphic comparing flu seasons and notes Trump Jr’s public suggestion that low flu numbers meant flu cases were being relabeled as COVID, helping fuel the “flu disappeared/it’s all COVID” narrative. |
| Myth: The Vaccines Were Rushed | Candace Owens and other early conservative commentators | New York Amsterdam News fact‑check referencing Owens’ tweet | The “rushed/experimental” framing existed broadly, but this fact‑check identifies a widely circulated Owens tweet repeating the talking point and influencing Black online spaces; it’s one of the earliest clearly documented high‑reach uses. |
| Myth: Vaccine Turbo Cancer | Alexandra Henrion‑Caude; Canadian anti‑vaccine doctors (Hoffe, Makis) | CancerDisinfo analysis of “turbo cancer” and France Culture’s “Autopsie des fake news scientifiques” episode on turbo‑cancers | These sources explicitly trace the term’s popularization to Henrion‑Caude and note overlapping circles with Hoffe and Makis, who pushed anecdotal “turbo cancer” stories on social media and alternative media during the COVID vaccine rollout. |
| Myth: Vaccines Don’t Stop Transmission | Natural News network; Alec Zeck tweet | Britannica/NewsGuard piece tracing myth to a July 2021 Natural News article ; TheJournal.ie fact‑check of Alec Zeck’s November 2021 tweet | Natural News misrepresented CDC director Walensky’s comments about Delta and viral load, framing vaccinated people as “super‑spreaders.” Zeck’s tweet (“product doesn’t even stop transmission”) then spread widely across Facebook groups, cementing the meme. |
| Myth: VAERS Proves Massive Injury and Death from COVID Vaccines | Long‑standing anti‑vaccine networks; early TikTok/FB videos | PolitiFact on TikTok claim “5,946 people have died because of the vaccine” based on VAERS | VAERS misuse predates COVID (e.g., National Vaccine Information Center and similar groups), but this TikTok video is an early, high‑visibility COVID‑specific instance claiming VAERS “proves” thousands of deaths, then reposted widely on Facebook. |
| Myth: Side Effects on Vaccine Package Inserts | Misreading of Pfizer regulatory documents; social posts recycling “side‑effect lists” | FactCheckHub, PolitiFact, and Reuters on the misused Pfizer adverse‑event document | These fact‑checks show that viral posts copied long lists of “side effects” from a 2021 Pfizer submission to FDA and framed them as confirmed side effects on inserts. The earliest viral origin they can trace is social media posts sharing screenshots of that document, not Pfizer itself. |
Myths where a precise “first origin” can’t be reliably identified
For the rest of the myths on your page, the pattern is similar: we can see who amplified them early and at scale, but not the very first spark. In most cases, the myth emerges from a mix of:
- Pre‑existing anti‑vaccine/anti‑public‑health narratives (e.g., “do your own research,” “natural immunity is better,” “99% survival rate,” “it’s just a flu”).
- Early pandemic political commentary and talk‑radio/YouTube ecosystems.
- Anonymous or low‑signal social posts that aren’t archived or searchable now.
Briefly, by category:
- Myth: “Flatten the Curve” Didn’t Work Likely roots: early 2020 anti‑lockdown commentators and blogs arguing that mitigation failed once cases rose again; heavily amplified by U.S. and UK right‑wing media, but no single identifiable “first” post survives in the record.
- Myth: 99% “Survival Rate” / “It’s Just a Flu” / “COVID Is Renamed Influenza” / “It’s Not a Risk for the Healthy” / “It’s Not Dangerous for Children”Likely roots:
- Early minimization by political figures and pundits comparing COVID to seasonal flu.
- Misuse of crude infection‑fatality estimates on Twitter, Facebook, and blogs.
- These tropes are so widely repeated across platforms from March–April 2020 onward that any “earliest” instance is effectively untraceable now.
- Myth: “Do Your Own Research” The phrase predates COVID by years as a general conspiracy‑culture slogan; COVID simply gave it new content. There is no single origin—more a meme of distrust that migrated into pandemic discourse.
- Myth: From COVID vs With COVID Emerged from early debates over death certification and hospital reporting; quickly taken up by commentators arguing numbers were inflated. Multiple outlets and influencers pushed it in parallel; again, no single, verifiable first online source.
- Myth: I Had Mild COVID, I’m Fine / Omicron Is Mild These are experiential minimizations that spread organically as people posted their own stories; later amplified by commentators framing Omicron as “nature’s vaccine.” The “origin” is countless individual posts rather than one propagator.
- Myth: Ivermectin for COVID This one has many documented early nodes—small preprints, FLCCC promotion, Joe Rogan’s podcast, and right‑wing media—but the first online claim that ivermectin “cures” COVID is buried in early 2020 forums and Facebook groups that aren’t cleanly searchable now.
- Myth: Masks Don’t Work Originates from a mix of:
- Early confusion over changing guidance.
- Long‑standing anti‑mask sentiment in some political circles.
- Misinterpretation of RCTs on influenza masks. Multiple blogs, YouTube channels, and commentators pushed it simultaneously; no single traceable first post.
- Myth: Natural Immunity Is Better than Vaccination A very old trope in anti‑vaccine rhetoric, repurposed for COVID. Its roots go back decades in measles/varicella discussions; COVID‑specific versions are just the latest iteration.
- Myth: Clot Shots The slang itself appears to have emerged organically in anti‑vax Telegram/Twitter circles once rare clotting events with adenovirus vaccines were reported. It’s a meme, not a single authored claim, and early uses are scattered across now‑buried posts.
- Myth: We Don’t Know the Long‑Term Effects of the Vaccine This is a generic uncertainty argument used for many new technologies. COVID‑specific versions show up in early 2020–2021 vaccine‑hesitant posts, but again, there’s no single identifiable “first” origin—just a widespread rhetorical move.
Why this can’t be fully “solved”
To do what you’re asking in a truly forensic way—for every myth:
- We’d need complete, time‑ordered archives of Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, blogs, forums, and messaging apps from early 2020 onward, including deleted content.
- We’d have to disambiguate parallel invention (different people arriving at the same myth independently) from direct copying.
- We’d still end up with “earliest known surviving instance,” not a guaranteed true origin.
Given those constraints, the table above is the most honest level of specificity I can give: early, documented propagators and key amplification points for some myths, and a clear explanation of why others resist precise origin tracing.
If you want, we can zoom in on one or two myths you care most about (e.g., turbo cancer, ivermectin, masks) and build a more detailed timeline of how they evolved and who pushed them at each stage—that’s much more tractable than trying to nail down “the first person ever” for all of them.
Gemini
Here is a breakdown of the origins and early appearances online for each of the myths featured on the ICEMSG Myths page
.
1. Myth: “Flatten the Curve” Didn’t Work
- Earliest Origins: The “Flatten the Curve” visual concept originated in a 2007 CDC report (Interim Pre-pandemic Planning Guidance). The myth that it “didn’t work” or was a total failure began circulating in April–May 2020 as stay-at-home orders were extended beyond the initial “15 Days to Slow the Spread.”
- Early Entities: Libertarian commentators, conservative media outlets, and anti-lockdown organizers on Facebook and Twitter (such as the “Reopen” movement groups formed in mid-April 2020).
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: Early editorial pieces and social posts, such as The Federalist’s commentary on non-pharmaceutical interventions (March/April 2020), argued the curve was never meant to stop total infections and claimed the policy failed.
2. Myth: 99% “Survival Rate”
- Earliest Origins: This myth emerged in March–April 2020 when early infection fatality rate (IFR) estimates were conflated with overall population survival rates, ignoring age-stratified mortality and long-term morbidity.
- Early Entities: Social media posts on Twitter/X and Facebook, quickly amplified by public figures including Donald Trump Jr. and various conservative political influencers in April 2020 quoting raw division of deaths over total population.
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: Early viral tweets and memes referencing “99.9% survival rate” began circulating widely on Twitter in April 2020.
3. Myth: Clot Shots
- Earliest Origins: The derogatory term “Clot Shot” emerged in March–April 2021 following reports of Rare Thrombosis with Thrombocytopenia Syndrome (TTS) linked to the AstraZeneca and Johnson & Johnson adenoviral vector vaccines.
- Early Entities: Alternative health bloggers, anti-vaccine influencers on Telegram and Rumble, and doctors on anti-vaccine circuits (such as Dr. Charles Hoffe in British Columbia, Canada, who publicly claimed in April 2021 that mRNA vaccines cause microscopic blood clots).
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: Discussion threads on Reddit and BitChute using the term proliferated in March/April 2021.
4. Myth: COVID Is Renamed Influenza
- Earliest Origins: Promoted heavily in February–March 2020 and resurfaced in Late 2020 when public health measures (masks, distancing) led to a historically low flu season.
- Early Entities:QAnon networks, Telegram channels, and figures like David Icke and Alex Jones (InfoWars), who argued that doctors were labeling ordinary flu cases as COVID-19 to inflate panic.
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: Articles on InfoWars and posts on 4chan/8kun in March 2020 claiming flu cases were reclassified as COVID-19.
5. Myth: “Do Your Own Research”
- Earliest Origins: A long-standing slogan within wellness and anti-vaccination communities that predates COVID-19 (used widely in anti-MMR vaccine circles since the early 2000s by groups like Children’s Health Defense / World Mercury Project).
- Early Entities: Pre-pandemic anti-vaccine organizations (Children’s Health Defense, National Vaccine Information Center) and wellness influencers on Instagram/Facebook.
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: Early anti-vaccine blog posts on Children’s Health Defense and various anti-vax forums dating back to 2016–2018.
6. Myth: From COVID vs. With COVID
- Earliest Origins: Emerged in April–May 2020 when death certificate reporting guidelines (distinguishing primary vs. contributing causes) were misinterpreted by critics of public health metrics.
- Early Entities: Conservative political commentators, blogs such as The Gateway Pundit, and anti-lockdown activists claiming CDC data showed only 6% of listed deaths were “actually from COVID.”
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: August 2020 viral posts misinterpreting CDC Comorbidity tables, widely covered and amplified by The Gateway Pundit in August 2020.
7. Myth: I Had Mild COVID, I’m Fine
- Earliest Origins: A common misconception that arose early in the pandemic (Spring 2020) when initial messaging focused primarily on hospitalization and acute respiratory distress.
- Early Entities: Mainstream news outlets initially framing COVID-19 as a binary “mild vs. severe” respiratory disease, which was later adopted by lockdown skeptics minimizing post-acute sequelae (Long COVID).
8. Myth: It’s Just a Flu
- Earliest Origins:January–February 2020, during the initial outbreak in Wuhan and early international spread.
- Early Entities: Promoted widely by conservative political figures, media hosts (such as Fox News commentators in early March 2020), and former U.S. President Donald Trump during early press briefings in February/March 2020.
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: Public statements and broadcast interviews from February/March 2020 comparing coronavirus directly to the seasonal flu.
9. Myth: It’s Not a Risk for the Healthy
- Earliest Origins: Formulated in Spring 2020 and codified formally in October 2020 with the publication of the Great Barrington Declaration.
- Early Entities: Co-authors of the Great Barrington Declaration (Martin Kulldorff, Sunetra Gupta, Jay Bhattacharya) sponsored by the libertarian think tank American Institute for Economic Research (AIER).
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: The official launch page of the Great Barrington Declaration (October 4, 2020).
10. Myth: It’s Not Dangerous for Children
- Earliest Origins: Circulated heavily starting in Summer 2020 during debates around school reopenings.
- Early Entities: School reopening advocacy groups, political commentators, and organizations like Urgency of Normal.
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: Op-eds and policy briefs in Wall Street Journal Opinion and social media campaigns from July–August 2020.
11. Myth: Ivermectin for COVID
- Earliest Origins:April 2020, following an in vitro Australian study (Caly et al., Monash University) showing high doses of ivermectin inhibited SARS-CoV-2 in cell culture.
- Early Entities:FLCCC (Front Line COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance) led by Dr. Pierre Kory and Dr. Paul Marik, along with Latin American health figures promoting off-label usage in mid-2020.
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: The original research paper published in Antiviral Research in April 2020 and FLCCC’s launch in Late 2020.
12. Myth: Masks Don’t Work
- Earliest Origins: Gained traction in April–May 2020 after public health agencies updated their initial guidance regarding community masking.
- Early Entities: Anti-mask advocacy groups, conservative commentary outlets, and later reinforced by misinterpretations of the Cochrane Review on physical interventions (Tom Jefferson et al.).
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: Anti-mask political rallies and articles published on sites like AIER and Ludwig von Mises Institute in May 2020.
13. Myth: Natural Immunity is Better than Vaccination
- Earliest Origins: Emerged in Late 2020 / Early 2021 as vaccines were rolled out and vaccine mandates were proposed.
- Early Entities:Children’s Health Defense, America’s Frontline Doctors (AFLDS), and proponents of focused protection / herd immunity strategies.
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: AFLDS whitepapers and blog posts on Children’s Health Defense in January–March 2021.
14. Myth: Omicron Is Mild
- Earliest Origins:November–December 2021, immediately following the identification of the Omicron variant (B.1.1.529) in South Africa.
- Early Entities: Initial news summaries quoting early observations from South African medical practitioners (e.g., Dr. Angelique Coetzee), which were rapidly generalized by commentators to claim Omicron posed minimal population threat.
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: International news coverage in late November 2021 quoting initial South African clinical observations.
15. Myth: The Flu Magically Disappeared
- Earliest Origins:Late 2020 / Early 2021, during the northern hemisphere winter when influenza surveillance reported historically low rates.
- Early Entities: Anti-vaccine groups, COVID skeptics, and conspiracy channels on Telegram and Twitter claiming influenza cases were simply re-labeled as COVID-19.
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: Posts on social media referencing WHO and CDC influenza surveillance graphs from December 2020.
16. Myth: The Vaccines Were Rushed
- Earliest Origins:May–August 2020, following the announcement of “Operation Warp Speed” by the U.S. government.
- Early Entities: Mainstream media outlets initially raising safety questions about the accelerated timeline, later adopted and expanded by anti-vaccine networks.
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: Articles and commentaries across major news sites and blogs in May 2020.
17. Myth: Vaccine Turbo Cancer
- Earliest Origins:Late 2021 / Early 2022, gaining significant traction after a misinterpreted laboratory mouse study (Eens et al., Frontiers in Oncology) and anecdotal claims by anti-vaccine figures.
- Early Entities:Dr. Ryan Cole, Dr. William Makis, and Stephanie Seneff / Peter McCullough in published papers suggesting mRNA immune suppression mechanisms.
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: Blog posts by anti-vaccine commentators and articles on Science-Based Medicine evaluating the term’s emergence in 2022.
18. Myth: Vaccines Don’t Stop Transmission
- Earliest Origins: Popularized in Mid-to-Late 2021 with the emergence of the Delta variant and subsequent breakthrough infections.
- Early Entities: Skeptics and anti-vaccine organizations pointing to viral load studies (such as the Barnstable County, MA outbreak report in July 2021) to argue vaccines provided zero transmission benefit.
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: CDC MMWR report on the Barnstable County outbreak in July 2021 and subsequent commentary on social platforms.
19. Myth: VAERS Proves Massive Injury and Death from COVID Vaccines
- Earliest Origins:January–February 2021, immediately as public COVID-19 vaccination efforts began and initial unverified reports were submitted to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System.
- Early Entities:Children’s Health Defense (Robert F. Kennedy Jr.), Alex Berenson, and Tucker Carlson (Fox News segments in May 2021 citing raw VAERS numbers).
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: Weekly “VAERS report summaries” published by Children’s Health Defense starting in January 2021.
20. Myth: We Don’t Know the Long-Term Effects of the Vaccine
- Earliest Origins:Late 2020, prior to and during emergency use authorizations (EUAs) for the mRNA vaccines.
- Early Entities: Anti-vaccine advocacy organizations, wellness influencers, and vaccine-hesitant groups on Facebook and Instagram.
- Earliest Archive/Link Reference: Online petitions and social media campaigns in November–December 2020 arguing against EUAs due to lack of multi-year clinical trial data.
